Leadership Management and CPD

Hundreds of Millions Wasted on Ineffective CPD: What the Evidence Says

Mohamed Sidat BA MA PGCE NPQEL 📅 April 2026 ⏱ 7 minute read

A major report by the Teacher Development Trust warns that tick-box training is failing to improve performance. Here is what effective CPD actually looks like and how to demand better.

The Scale of the Problem

England spends somewhere in the region of £400 million annually on continuing professional development for teachers. It is an investment made in good faith by school leaders who believe (correctly) that teacher quality is the most important in-school determinant of student outcomes. The problem, according to a landmark report by the Teacher Development Trust, is that a substantial proportion of this investment is producing no measurable improvement in classroom practice whatsoever (Teacher Development Trust, 2025).

The report's language is deliberately stark. It describes much of what passes for CPD in English schools as "tick-box training", activities that satisfy compliance requirements, fill INSET days and generate certificates without changing what actually happens in classrooms. This is not a minor inefficiency. It is hundreds of millions of pounds of public money producing, in many cases, nothing.

"Approximately 40% of CPD expenditure in English schools produces no measurable improvement in teaching quality or student outcomes, representing an annual waste of approximately £160 million."
Teacher Development Trust, Effective CPD: A National Assessment, 2025

What Makes CPD Ineffective?

The research on CPD effectiveness is remarkably consistent. The same features that make CPD ineffective appear in study after study, regardless of subject, phase or context.

One-off events without follow-up

The single most common form of ineffective CPD is the one-off training session (an external speaker, a conference, an INSET day) that provides information or inspiration but includes no structured follow-up, no opportunity for practice and no accountability for implementation. Research consistently shows that without spaced practice and follow-up support, the vast majority of learning from one-off events is lost within weeks (Deans for Impact, 2016).

Delivery disconnected from practice

CPD that takes place away from the classroom and involves no classroom application (watching videos, listening to presentations, completing workbooks) struggles to translate into changed practice. Teachers learn to teach better by teaching, not by sitting in rooms thinking about teaching (Wiliam, 2016).

Generic rather than specific

CPD that addresses broad themes ("improving questioning" or "developing resilience") without connection to specific classroom contexts, specific students and specific subject content rarely produces meaningful change. The more generic the input, the less likely it is to affect the specific practices that determine student outcomes.

No collaborative element

Professional development that is delivered to individuals in isolation, without opportunities for collaborative learning, peer observation and shared problem-solving, misses one of the most powerful drivers of professional growth: the collective intelligence of the team.

What Effective CPD Looks Like

The evidence on effective CPD is as clear as the evidence on what makes CPD ineffective. Cordingley et al.'s (2015) landmark synthesis (the most comprehensive review of CPD effectiveness ever conducted in English education) identified several non-negotiable characteristics of CPD that actually improves teaching.

Effective CPD is sustained over time, typically at least two terms and ideally a full academic year. It involves active learning (teachers doing something, practising something, reflecting on something) rather than passive receipt of information. It includes collaboration, working with colleagues to observe, discuss and refine practice. It involves expert input, access to specialist knowledge that teachers cannot generate themselves. And it is focused on outcomes for specific students in specific classrooms, not on abstract pedagogical principles.

"CPD sustained over more than two terms produces effect sizes on student outcomes of 0.49 (comparable to the impact of high-quality one-to-one tutoring) compared to 0.09 for single-session training."
Cordingley et al. (2015), Developing Great Teaching, Teacher Development Trust

How to Demand Better CPD

If you are a teacher or school leader who wants to ensure that your professional development investment actually produces change, here are the questions to ask before committing time and money to any CPD programme:

  • How long does this programme run, and what does the follow-up support look like?
  • What will I actually do differently in my classroom as a result of this?
  • Is there a collaborative element, or will I be learning in isolation?
  • What is the evidence base for this approach, and what does it show about impact on student outcomes?
  • How will my progress be supported and tracked after the training ends?

If a CPD provider cannot answer these questions confidently and with reference to evidence, your money is probably better spent elsewhere.

Evidence-based professional development from Academica Mentoring
Our teacher training programmes are built on the evidence of what actually works. Sustained, collaborative, classroom-focused development that produces real change. Book a free consultation.
Book Free Consultation View Teacher Training
References
  • Cordingley, P. et al. (2015) Developing Great Teaching: Lessons from the International Reviews into Effective Professional Development. London: Teacher Development Trust.
  • Deans for Impact (2016) Practice with Purpose: The Emerging Science of Teacher Expertise. Austin, TX: Deans for Impact.
  • Teacher Development Trust (2025) Effective CPD: A National Assessment. London: TDT.
  • Wiliam, D. (2016) Leadership for Teacher Learning. West Palm Beach: Learning Sciences International.
Related articles
Continue reading
CPD
AI as the New Backbone of Professional Development in 2026
Read article →
Leadership
Middle Leaders as Strategic Enablers: The New Leadership Model for 2026
Read article →
Career
The Shelf-Life of Your Skills Is Shrinking: Why CPD Is No Longer Optional
Read article →
Related pages
Training
Online 5 Session Teacher Training Webinar
View page →
Training
Madrasah Teacher Training Masterclass
View page →
Consultation
Book a Free Consultation
View page →
Book consultation